I’m sorry that this post is rather long, but it is a complicated subject.
First, I need to say that we have a gun in our house. When my husband was a teenager, his father gave him a .22 rifle. They would go out hunting a couple of times a year, shared moments of quiet in the woods between a father and son, with sometimes a squirrel brought home to be stewed or fried. The father is gone, the rifle oiled and wrapped carefully and stored, probably not to be used again. But it is kept and I would not ask that we get rid of it.
Also, my son-in-law has a gun at his house. It is kept clean and oiled, locked in a gun cabinet, but ready to use if coyotes or other animals threaten his calves. He fires to scare the animals, and would kill them only if they were actually dangerous (rabies, etc).
So I cannot say that all guns should be banned, I just cannot be that hypocritical. But I do have major misgivings with the attitude of many people here toward guns.
Some background: Hunting and rifles run through US history- the settlers that came to this natural land felt the need for protection and wanted to feed their families. A man carving out a niche for himself and his family would keep a rifle (musket) handy, to be used if necessary to defend from dangerous animals or people, but mostly to add meat to their diets. Many had come from countries where they could do neither- as tenant farmers, they could not defend themselves nor hunt game. This desire to be independent was a strong force, we call it the ‘pioneering spirit’, and the rifle was just a tool to help them.
While few families now hunt to feed themselves, many retain the hunting tradition, using it as a bond between fathers and sons, and sometimes with daughters, too. These are the majority of gun owners in the USA, and although I don’t like hunting, I don’t have a problem with people who choose to hunt, if they follow rules and safety procedures.
Now we come to what I perceive as the major problems (**with some personal notes):
A. Laws concerning firearms vary widely from state to state, with too many states having very lax laws or poor enforcement of existing laws.
**There needs to be a strong, consistent, national law requiring background checks, waiting periods, and registration of all firearms.
B. People who feel vulnerable will sometimes legally buy and keep a handgun in their homes for protection. Often these guns accidentally or through carelessness kill the owners, or their children.
**The laws should be stricter and harder to circumvent. There should be required classes.
C. Under the guise of the 2nd amendment to the US Constitution, some people claim that they are guaranteed the right to own any kind of gun that they wish. People who need to feel empowered will buy large handguns and high-powered rifles/assault weapons, to make themselves feel ‘macho’. Most of these people will never shoot anyone, they just want to swagger. But this puts these guns on the open market, where anyone can get them, one way or another. A criminal will not heed gun registration laws or regulations.
** These yahoos need to grow up, get over it, and find another hobby. We don’t need any of these guns in private hands.
D. A person who qualifies can get a gun legally and later turn violent.
**When someone turns violent, they will use what is at hand, be it gun, knife, baseball bat, or automobile. Outlawing handguns and automatic weapons will help by limiting their choice of weapons, but it is treating the symptoms, not the cause. There are deeper issues here.
The debate in the USA is intense and has been going on as long as I can remember. The National Rifle Association and other groups have the strongest lobby, and legislation is fought every step of the way. The laws that are passed are challenged in the courts and loopholes abound. If the local authorities turn a blind eye, the laws may as well not exist. It would seem that an incident like the killings at Virginia Tech would make people change their minds about gun control, but that is apparently not the case. Americans can be a stubborn lot, and I’m afraid we’ll continue to shoot ourselves in the foot rather than face the facts.
**discussion and questions are welcome, but please don’t yell at me.
Thursday, April 26, 2007
Guns in the USA
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


Digg This!
8 comments:
Hi Jane. I respect your reasons for owning a gun. I think owning a gun is a big responsibility. My husband and I had many discussions in the past about getting a gun (let me stress LEGAL gun) for the house as some form of protection/for emergency cases. I have expressed my objections about getting a gun and he has given in to my request.
It's a very good post, Jane. Very informative as well. I have no idea where the problem is or how your laws need to change, but I think they do need that change. Unfortunately it seems tragedies such as Virginia Tech and Columbine are not strong enough to alter the way most people think about guns. Guns may not cause aggression, but surely without them no massacre could occur.
I'm wondering how Canadians deal with that problem as they have always been closely related to the USA. Perhaps our friend Leon could tell us.
Hi Jane;
Congratulations for such an excelent article. I respect your reasons, I understand the reasons of your country, I am aware of USA History and I follow with close attention your politics and politicians. I also agree having a gun it is a huge responsability.
In my country having a gun, - hunting, defense, shooting (sports) - requires lots of paper work. Unfortunately, nowadays, there are lots of guns in the wrong hands, with no paper work attached.
It is always a pleasure reading you.
Greetings.
I.
Thank you all, I spent a lot of time in the writing, trying to make my thoughts clear.
It is obvious that we have problems with guns in this country, especially when a person who should not have been able to purchase any gun can buy two and with the ability to fire 170 rounds within a few minutes. After President Reagan was shot in 1981, there was some progress made in controlling handguns and access to them, but it is so hard to make progress.
Hi Jane I see that you read my post about the new weapon laws in Belgium. And to answer your question concerning knives, they are also not allowed to carry with you. Everything you could use as a weapon is legally not allowed.
It's sad to hear that so many people in the USA are still thinking they would live more safe with a gun. As long as this exists, such things like VT will always happen. You see everything can also happen in other countries but not at such a level as in the USA. I also never heard about a sniper acting here just shooting for pleasure.
Filip, here is an article that might explain better than I could why it is so hard to change the laws here: CWN article It's a bit biased, but does have good information.
The comments are pretty interesting/scary, also.
Gattina, I was asking about the knife and box cutter to see how the law in your country deals with items that are not purely weapons.
If I understand, while you have knives at home, restaurants, etc, you must leave them there, they cannot be carried around. So my pocket knife would have to stay at home, and my box cutter would have to stay at work. Correct?
There are many efforts here to restrict things like sniper scopes, large caliber guns, automatic weapons, etc, but the gun makers give a lot of money to the lobby groups to block these laws. And the laws that are passed end up in court where they are tugged back and forth. Some courts rule in favor of restrictions, some against. It often depends on politics.
Hi Jane:)
First of all i have to make it clear that i only know your country from tv, movies, geography or history lessons (so i have no clue about how it really is).
Now i see two USA-s: the Flower power country, the peace and love, save the planet, love your neighbour; freedom and humanism etc. and the country involved in all recent wars, the country where many people have a gun in the house, where it happens to be shot in school, where advertising sales junk food as perfectly safe healthy food. I would realy like to learn about those things. If they are real, how do they match. I know your country is large enough for all those facts, but...i would still want to know what's the real main opinion. I would like to know your opinion because i know how media can twist information, it happens in my country too:)
liv
@livia,
Hello. I think you answered your own question- the USA is large enough for all of those things.
As a land of immigrants, we have a bit of all cultures here, and so you can find just about anything somewhere within our borders. Consider also that the USA is about the size of all of Europe, although with a bit less people. You expect the variation in Europe, but may be surprised at it in the USA. While we share a government and a language (mostly), people have their own interpretations of what is right and proper. The church-going pilar of the community also believes in the right to bear arms. The anti-gun person works at McDonald's. The health-food advocate drives a gas-guzzling SUV.
So the best answer I can give you is yes, the USA is all those things because each person is all those things in some combination.
Post a Comment